Showing posts with label chapter 3. Show all posts
Showing posts with label chapter 3. Show all posts

Wednesday, 25 May 2016

Keith and Stephen’s Relationship




All along Chapter 3, there are many sentences that suggest that Stephen is convinced of Keith’s total superiority and that he accepts it blindly, disregarding any evidence that points to the contrary. His low self-esteem and his sense of inferiority can account for this conviction.


The narrator uses a clear metaphor to describe Keith and Stephen´s asymmetrical relationship: Keith is the “hero” whereas Stephen  is just his “sword bearer”. Therefore, Stephen`s role is limited to follow, help and obey his friend´s orders.  At times, Stephen´s subordination is shown in the way he copies his friend's words:  “‘Nothing´ says Keith. ‘Nothing’ I confirm.” But mostly, Stephen´s voice seems to be annihilated by Keith´s, as the following quotations illustrate: “One of my tasks as his sword-bearer, though, is to prompt his imagination by offering useless suggestions.” “If theories involving secret passages, rockets, time travel, and the like are to carry conviction, they have to be uttered in his voice, not mine.” Moreover, Keith seems to have the power not only to silence Stephen but also to govern his behaviour and thoughts: “(…) I humbly wait for Keith to announce what we’re to think and what we’re to do”.Evidently, their relationship seems to be more an autocracy than a democracy.


Stephen´s admiration for Keith goes so far as to speak of him as a deity: “(...) he is more than a protagonist in the events we are living through- (...) he is in some mysterious way their creator.” Like God´s in the Book of Genesis, Keith´s words have creating power: “In each case he uttered the words, and the words became so. He told the story and the story came to life” The six words “my mother is a German spy” generated a new world for the children, as well as the story of the novel. Stephen does not possess this same power. When he says his father is also a German spy, the only reaction Keith has is a faint movement of his lips in  “a slight dismissive amusement”


If Keith is a God, Stephen is his most faithful acolyte. Not only does Stephen praise Keith all the time in these chapters, but he even silences any doubt he may have about the legitimacy of his friend's  leadership: “I have private reservations about the spelling but keep them to myself, as I do any of the other small occasional reservations I have about his authority.” His low self-esteem and his inferiority complex are the two conditions for this admiration not to be shaken by any conflicting evidence. If Keith misspells a word, Stephen dismisses his doubts, and blindly accepts Keith´s spelling. In chapter 5, he is even ready to own up to his friend's mistakes as if they were his own: “I want to lie and say it was me to spare Keith´s shame (...)”.

Will Stephen´s subservience continue all along the book? Well, that is the question we will have to answer as we go on reading.

Monday, 23 May 2016

Minor characters in chapter 3

  Mrs.Elmsley was Mrs Hayward's housemaid. She seemed suspicious to Stephen just because she has a moustache and a wart in the middle of her forehead, and she speaks very softly. Stephen had never wondered before why she looked like that, but after Keith accused her mother of being a German spy,  the children considered all the characters to whom she spoke possible accomplices.

   Another character who seemed suspicious to Stephen was Mr. Hucknall, the butcher. He sung humorously loud and tossed the sniking brass weights from hand to hand.Stephen thought his behaviour was just pretence to conceal his true nature and that the mutton chops in his orders could be a secret code.

   To conclude, Stephen was just a boy with a fertile imagination. After his friend uttered the six words, even these two minor characters, Mrs. Elmsley and  Mr. Hucknall become suspicious for him so the reader can't help doubting the reliability of his perspective.

Our Attitutude Towards Keith and Stephen´s projects in chapter 3.

In the book, Stephen and Keith seem to have discovered a very dark secret: Mrs. Hayward is a German spy. Throughout chapter 3, we read how the two imaginative kids spy on Keith's mother. At many points in this chapter, we, readers, doubt about the seriousness of the children´s investigation. We can not share their beliefs because we are aware that they don´t fully understand how the world works, and so we start having a cynical and distrustful attitude towards their projects.

To begin with, everything that they are spying on are ordinary events that they previously took for granted (Mrs Hayward´s excursions to the shops or the post, her conversations with the butcher or the maid, etc) The fact that they suspiciously inspect and doubt every single action or person that are related to Mrs. Hayward  gives us the impression that the whole investigation is just a figment of their vivid imagination. However, Stephen and Keith, believe that there is a real problem going on in the Close and their task is of the utmost importance . This is shown when Stephen thinks "But then what can we do, if she's a German spy? We have to make sacrifices for the War Effort" or when he says "We have to defend our homeland from its enemies". These quotes show that they think that they have a significant role in the war, which we only see as part of their naive perspective.

Keith's ability to invent new mysteries for them to investigate is another reason that accounts for our lack of trust in their ideas. For example, they have already looked into the alleged crimes of Mr Gort. Their discovery of buried bones in his backyard lead them to write a letter  to Mr MacAffee, whom Stephen describes as "a kind of policeman",  Their expectations that Mr MacAffee would arrest Mr Gort was not fulfilled, which proves that the whole investigation was only part of their childish imagination.  This previous experience leads us to think that Keith's mother being a German spy is not any more true than Mr Gort´s murder story.

All this attitude is related to Franco Molina's posts on the reliability of the narrator. In his post he argues that we can not completely rely on the narrator not only because the old Stephen doesn´t remember the order of events clearly but also because he tells many parts of the story from young Stephen´s perspective, i.e. a perspective which is affected by his lack of knowledge and experience and by his inferiority complex.

In conclusion, in this chapter, our attitude towards the kids' activities is one of mistrust. We believe that all their investigation is part of their lack of understanding of the adults´ world and a creation of their childish imagination.

Saturday, 21 May 2016

Keith's Spelling

Keith had a lot of spelling mistakes in comparison with Stephen. Although Keith went to the "right" school and Stephen to the "wrong one", Keith's spelling was far from perfect.

There are many examples of these mistakes in chapter 3. When Keith and Stephen found the exercise book that they were going to use to record their investigations, Keith wrote on its cover: "LOGBOOK -SECRIT" meaning secret. One of the first entries in that logbook was  Keith's mother conversation with Mr. Hucknall, the butcher: "1053 hrs. Phones. Asks for 8087. Mr. Hucknall. 3 muten chops. Not to fat", meaning "mutton" and "too" Another example of Keith's spelling mistakes was when he wrote "Privet" on a tile at the entrance of the passageway. He didn't want to refer to the plant, what he really meant was "private".

These mistakes clearly show that Keith is not superior to Stephen in all aspects, as Stephen believes, As we have said in other posts, that is Stephen´s opinion, but he is not a reliable narrator as -among other reasons- his point of view is tainted by his low self-esteem. 
Stephen knew the spelling of these words was wrong but he preferred to keep it to himself because he felt inferior. He was used to being "the led" and to accepting anything Keith said. He never dared to question the leader. Keith is like a god to Stephen and he admires him and he thinks that whatever he does is right and should be humbly accepted.


Dramatic irony

According to Enciclopaedia Britannica, dramatic irony is defined as “ a literary device by which the audience’s or reader’s understanding of events or individuals in a work surpasses that of its characters.” (http://www.britannica.com/art/dramatic-irony)
In chapter 3 of Spies,  dramatic irony occurs when Keith and Stephen discover the x´s and the !´s in Mrs. Hayward´s diary. These events are described by young Stephen, who has the innocence of a little kid, but we -readers- understand their findings in a different way because we have more knowledge and experience.
The x´s appear in Mrs. Hayward's´diary once a month, some months 2 days earlier or later than others. We realise immediately what meaning the x´s have: they mark Keith´s mother´s menstrual period. However, Keith and Stephen have no knowledge of this so they relate them to their belief that Keith´s mother was a German spy. They conclude that the x´s record her meetings with the Germans. Besides, her menstrual period coincide with the nights of no moon: "Yes, the x´s are approximately keeping step with the lunar calendar. Each month the x is close to the same sign, the full black circle. The night of no moon". So the children infer that dark nights are ideal for these meetings.
After working on the hypothesis about the meaning of the x´s, the children find the little exclamation marks: "The exclamation marks however, happened only 3 times so far this year, and at irregular intervals- on a Saturday in January, on another Saturday in March and on a Tuesday in April. These last date, I´m somehow disturbed to see, is also marked "wedding anniv.""  Keith and Stephen are not able to build up any consistent  theory about  these exclamation marks, but we assume that they keep track of Mr. Hayward and Mrs. Hayward's´sexual activity, which was important in case of pregnancy.
To conclude, there is a gap between our deductions and Stephen and Keith´s due to the character's lack of information about sexual matters. That explains why it is possible to speak about dramatic irony in this chapter.

Tuesday, 17 May 2016

Quiz (chapters 1 to 3)


Spies.Quiz (chapters 1 to 3).
Designed by Senior III-B students under the guidance of their teacher, Karina Zanetti.

1-What is young Stephen´s best friend´s name?
2- What is Stephen´s job?
3-At what stage of life is he?
4-What is the setting at the beginning of chapter 1?
5-What does the smell remind him of?
6-Who tells Stephen where the smell comes from?
7-Why does Stephen repeat the word “liguster”?
8-What city does he go to for a few days?
9-How does he feel when he returns there?
10-What does Stephen and Keith think about Keith´s mother?
11-What are the six words Keith said at the end of chapter 2?
12-How does Stephen feel about this?
13-Who lives next door to Stephen?
14-Name all Stephen´s neighbours.
15-In which war did Keith´s father fight?
16-Who does the bayonet belong to?
17-Whose diary does Stephen find?







Monday, 16 May 2016

Braemar

            In Spies there is a very special place where Keith and Stephen used to play together: Braemar. It used to be Miss Durrant´s house but very little remained of it as it had been destroyed by a stray  German incendiary bomb. The kids used it as their hideout and lookout and they planned all their games and adventures there.

              To start with, this "secret" place was full of vegetation due to the thick shrubs that used to be the front hedge of Mrs Durrant´s house. However, Keith and Stephen were able to pass through it and get to the middle of the undergrowth. Besides, among the shrubs there was the privet which the narrator  remembered and was looking for in the first chapter. The smell from these bushes is important because it is the catalyst for the whole story.

               For Keith and Stephen, Braemar was a secret place where they could get away from adults´ surveillance: "There´s only one place we can talk without being observed or overheard".There, they were away from the constraints imposed on them by the adults, and they were able to act following their own rules. It was as if they entered  a completely different world:  "Once we get there we´re across the frontier into another country altogether" They had to leave behind the refinement, luxury and politeness that governed Keith´s house: "We´ve come a long journey from the chocolate spread and the silver picture frames"
           Everything was different between the bushes, where the children´s imagination flowed. On the one hand, objects acquired a new meaning and importance. A  broken piece of metal from a shot-down German plane, the remains of Miss Durrant´s life or the units of ammunition Keith had traded at school were considered precious treasure  and were kept in a locked tin box. A long carving knife found out in the rubble of the house became the famous bayonet with which Mr Hayward had killed five Germans. On the other hand, the children´s behaviour turned wilder and more aggressive there. Stephen was made to take an oath on the sharpen “bayonet” that he would never speak about their investigations or his throat would be cut. This is the first instance in the novel in which they considered hurting each other dangerously.

             In the last part of chapter 2, Keith misspelt "private" and wrote "privet" instead. In Stephen´s memory, the two concepts were linked:  "privets" and their private place. It was only in this privacy (created by the privets)  that they could start their adventure. Their findings would be related to something private as it concerned one of their families and, as Keith made Stephen promise, it should remain private. The story stems both from the smell of the “privets” that are in a private place and from the children´s nosing into private matters.